Should have the colonists revolted against the British? Yes, the colonist revolted against the British. In 1776, the colonist had revolted against the British in because the British started to charge on all imported goods, they charged taxes on everything, on their goods, tea, and exporting products. The different motivations were the patriots and the loyalists. The patriots participated by boycotting British goods. There reasons for justifying the rebellion were an attempt to get the British to stop the taxation without representation.
The primary reason the colonists revolted was that they had been denied their rights as Englishmen. There was some argument that after the French and Indian War, Americans developed a feeling of “separateness” from the Empire, which is that they were more American and less English. This feeling of separateness accelerated after fighting broke out, but it was not the reason Americans rebelled in the first place. After the French and Indian War, Britain took the unusual step of taxing the colonists for the cost of the war.
Colonists had been taxed before, but those taxes had been levied by Colonial legislatures. They also had been taxed by Britain, but these taxes had been for purposes of regulation, than revenue. Most of the latter were evaded or ignored by the colonists as they smuggled goods to and from nations other than Great Britain. However, the attempt to tax the colonies (originally by the Stamp Act) violated one of the most sacred principles of the rights of Englishmen–the right to only be taxed by their duly elected representatives.
Several English diplomats attempted to explain this away by arguing such things as “virtual representation,” but this argument wasn’t as important. “Taxation without representation” soon became fighting words. James Dickinson expressed the feeling of the colonists eloquently. Dickinson may have overstated the cause; even after fighting broke out, the colonists offered to return to the British fold provided they were guaranteed their rights as Englishmen. The colonists were not pleased with these new taxes.
Before, the British policy was one of salutary neglect, which meant that they left the colonies alone and did not interfere with their affairs. Now, not only were the colonists being taxed but they were also not fairly represented in Parliament. Then, they had started to protest… After the protests against taxation started, then other rights were taken from the Colonists. They had to pay for British troops to police the Colonies, for example, they lost the right to have a free and open Assembly of elected men.
They also had the right to a trial by a jury of their peers (in America) taken away from them. As you might imagine this just increased the anger and distrust between the Colonists and Royal Authority. Finally, with the Boston Tea Party (a protest against taxation without representation), the British landed many more troops, and those troops set out into the countryside to take control of stores of black powder, muskets, lead shot and cannon. It was one of these “Powder Alarms” which turned into the Lexington and Concord fights that started the War.